Manager promotes all his employees except his top performer, who loses all motivation: 'He is hands down the best recruiter I've worked with among his peers.'

Author image for Emmy Pratt
Emmy Pratt • Writer and Editor
Feb 20, 2026 8:00 AM EST

He did the one thing that was almost guaranteed to demotivate him. 

It can be difficult to stay motivated to work hard when it's been proven that hard work doesn't yield tangible positive results. If an employee works harder and performs better than all of their coworkers, they should be rewarded for that work, even if it doesn't come in the form of a promotion or a raise. Their boss could give them a higher title or a bonus to communicate that their work is valued and does not go unnoticed. That might work for a year, but if a top-performing employee gets snubbed for a raise year after year, you can't be all that surprised when they try to find a new job somewhere where they are valued more. They know their hard work is making the company a whole lot of money, and that there are companies out there willing to pay bigger bucks for hardworking employees. 

It's one thing if everyone works sort of hard, and nobody gets the raises they deserve. Obviously, that's a bad situation, but at least people aren't getting rewarded for doing nothing. But if the best employee doesn't get promoted and everyone else does, how is he supposed to see that as anything less than a slap in the face? Why would you reward the employees who performed worse than the employee who performed the best? You shouldn't do that unless you're actively trying to get rid of your top performer. 

Add as a preferred
source on Google
Advertisement
  • Young handsome businessman in light modern office conducting a job interview
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • The recruiter in this story is probably going to leave soon. His manager claims he is the best recruiter in his peer group, yet he is the only one who didn't get promoted, apparently because he's "not ready to be a manager."

  • Management help: My only direct report is a "superstar" but has emotionally checked out. How do I save the relationship?

    I'm a Talent Acquisition Director in a high-pressure hotel environment. My team is just me and one TA Supervisor (1.5 years in).
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • He is technically excellent, the entire hotel rates him highly, and I've praised him recently to our Area Director as a future leader who will be ready to lead one of our future openings.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • However, he is emotionally reactive and very sensitive. Recently, every other employee in the office got promoted except him.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • Team of young coworkers dressed casually working together with laptops sitting at the round table in the office
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • He was understandably upset. A month ago, he sent me a late-night message saying "It's been a pleasure working with you." I managed to turn it around verbally; I told him I'm investing in him, we have a development plan, and the 2026 budget already has him allocated for an Assistant Manager role.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • He seemed hungry and motivated again. Things went south again this week due to two things: 1
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • The Documented Review: We did the verbal review (went well), but I just sent the formal document.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • I gave him "Fully Met" overall, but "Approached Expectations" in certain leadership behaviors (EQ, reactivity, big- picture thinking).
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • He isn't ready yet, and I wanted to be honest so we can bridge that gap this year.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • 2. The Idea Rejection: He suggested a "Welcome Video" for new hires. I told him it wasn't a priority right now and that he needs to focus on "need vs.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • elevation" (the bigger picture). He got very defensive and p ed off. Since sending that written review and rejecting the video idea, he has stopped sending his daily TA updates (which he usually does religiously).
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • I'm currently out of the office, and he's being very distant. He is technically an exceptional recruiter, hands down the best I've worked with among his peers.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • Young handsome businessman in light modern office for a job interview with directors
    via Getty Images (Unsplash+)

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • He proactively identifies hiring needs and fills positions before they are even posted officially. He has a fantastic relationships with hiring managers and stakeholders, and is generally a very communicative person, polite and is loved by everyone.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • • I have 10.5 months left this year to get him ready for that AM role.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • • We are a team of two; if he leaves or stays "checked out," the department stalls.
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • My Questions: 1 How do I re-engage a high-performer who feels "slighted" by an honest (but not perfect) written review?
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • 2. In a team of two, how do I handle the "silent treatment" without sounding like I'm micromanaging or begging?
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • 3. Is the "It's been a pleasure"/current silence combo a sign he's already interviewing elsewhere, or is this just an "ego bruise" I can coach him through on Sunday?
    via u/MutualUnderstanding7
  • Bjornwithit15 Superstar and only one not to get promoted. What did you expect? What would you do if your were them?
    via u/Bjornwithit15
  • FeeFiFoFumBB Why was everyone else promoted over this guy? Either there was no valid reason for that, in which case he's right in his anger, or there was a valid reason for that, in which case good riddance to him. So which is it?
    via u/FeeFiFoFumBB
  • throwtothesea23222 D in you really messed this up. Start looking for a replacement, cause that guy's sending resumes out right now. Edit: I can't spell words
    via u/throwtothesea23222
  • JimJamie James > I have 10.5 months No, I don't think you do.
    via u/JimJamieJames
  • DancingMooses I have a question. You say that the verbal review went well and he didn't have issues until you sent the written review. Did you actually tell him during the verbal review that you were going to give him "approaching expectations," on these behaviors? Because it sounds like he was surprised. And that's a really big problem if you plan on retaining this person.
    via u/DancingMooses
  • Slartibartfast0372 I have doubts that the relationship can be salvaged at this point. You can't promote everyone but him, still call him a superstar, and have him accept this. If I were him I would definitely be intereviewing at this point. 10.5 months is way too long to make him wait. I think the only way he's still around then is because he wasn't able to find another job yet. Your description of him and the way he's been treated just don't line up.
    via u/Slartibartfast0372
  • Street-Nothing9404 Put yourself if your employees shoes... they aren't clairvoyant. When "superstar" didn't get promoted and everyone else did... that's the opposite of rewarding "a superstar". And then you give "superstar" a good verbal review but neglected to tell him verbally that you need him to grow more and the reasons for that. Instead he got a written review that didn't align with the verbal review. DUDE. why should "superstar" trust you? From their perspective YOU are the reason for no
    via u/Street-Nothing9404
  • coldtrashpanda If he's amazing at his current job but not ready for a management role then you either slap a "2" / "II on the end of the title and give him a substantial raise or wind up with this situation where he is left wondering why he ever cared about doing well. Why on earth would he believe any promise of future compensation if going above and beyond already got him less than everyone else?
    via u/coldtrashpanda
  • Malfallaxx It sounds like you're giving him mixed signals and he's over it. After the debacle with him being the only one left out for a promotion you told him you had already budgeted for a large promotion for 2026, but now in his eyes you're backpedaling with the review saying he's not ready. Even in this post you say you have to 'get him ready' for the AM role, but you already told him he's got it and have talked about how much he's killing it. I don't blame him for checking out because he ha
    via u/Malfallaxx
  • Awkward-Dance123 You think you have time to coach him until he's "ready" for an AM role but you've been on borrowed time ever since he got passed up for the promotion. By all standards, it seems he has the technical and soft skills to get promoted but no promotion, gets nitpicked on "sensitivity", rebuffed on creative new ideas... These are signs he can easily read as you not investing in him. I don't know if this is something you can salvage without an honest conversation and a real attempt to
    via u/Awkward-Dance123

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

promotion motivation recruiter hotel manager coworkers performance review employees workplace top performer
Scroll Down For The Next Article